Texas state seal

Historical Opinions

Fourteenth Court of Appeals
Houston, Texas

OPINIONS DATED AUGUST 10, 2000


Civil

Published:  

14-98-01280-CV

United Parcel Service, Inc.
v.
Cengis Tasdermiroglu d/b/a CTC Computers
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Cannon, Draughn, and Lee (Metropolitan Backlog Reduction Task Force)
  Opinion by: Hon. Bill Cannon (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  Harris County Civil Court at Law No. 2 (Hon. Tom Sullivan)
  For appellant:  Keith Duane Jaasma and Amy Douhitt Maddux
  For appellee:  Murphy S. Klasing and David Purnell Andis


14-99-00611-CV

Bonnie Legere Pfeiffer
v.
James M. Jacobs, D.P.M.
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Fowler, Edelman, and Draughn
  Opinion by: Hon. Wanda McKee Fowler
  Trial court:  55th District Court (Hon. Sherry Radack)
  For appellant:  Wiley Doran, Walter J. Kronzer, III, and John Neal Spicer
  For appellee:  Carl Dawson


 
Unpublished: (Opinions not designated for publication have no precedential value and must not be cited as authority. See Tex. R. App. P. 47.7)

14-98-00488-CV

Annie F. Laas, et al.
v.
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Sears, Lee, and Dunn (Metropolitan Backlog Reduction Task Force)
  Opinion by: Hon. Norman Lee (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  270th District Court (Hon. Richard Hall)
  For appellant:  Randall L. Patterson
  For appellee:  Barbara L. Hachenburg


14-98-00621-CV

Texas Capital Bank, N.A.
v.
Annie M. Hoppe
  REVERSED AND RENDERED
  Panel:  Justices Sears, Cannon, and Lee (Metropolitan Backlog Reduction Task Force)
  Opinion by: Hon. Norman Lee (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  165th District Court (Hon. P.K. Reiter)
  For appellant:  Gregory M. Cokinos and Robert A. Plessala
  For appellee:  James E. Lindeman, III and Bruce Ian Schimmel


14-98-01284-CV

Delores Elena Taylor
v.
Ronald Dean Taylor
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Edelman, Wittig, and Lee (Lee sitting by assignment)
  Opinion by: Hon. Richard H. Edelman
  Trial court:  247th District Court (Hon. Letta Parks)
  For appellant:  Robert G. Miller
  For appellee:  Joe Villarreal


14-99-00076-CV

Lisa A. Louck
v.
Olshan Foundation Repair Company
  REVERSED AND REMANDED
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Opinion by: Hon. J. Harvey Hudson
  Trial court:  165th District Court (Hon. Elizabeth Ray)
  For appellant:  Roger A. Rider
  For appellee:  Owen Hammack Ellington and Mary C. Thompson


14-99-00197-CV

J. H. Hubbard
v.
Leon Davis
  AFFIRMED IN PART; REVERSED AND REMANDED IN PART
  Panel:  Justices Yates, Fowler, and Edelman
  Opinion by: Hon. Richard H. Edelman
  Trial court:  80th District Court (Hon. Scott Link)
  For appellant:  Jeffrey H. Hubbard
  For appellee:  Terry Garland Fry


14-99-00425-CV

Bruce Hill
v.
Gene Woods, et al.
  AFFIRMED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Justices Fowler, Edelman, and Draughn
  Trial court:  12th District Court (Hon. Erwin Ernst)
  For appellant:  Pro se
  For appellee:  Cari Gaye Bernstein


14-99-00428-CV

Curtis Mack Lewis
v.
Wayne Scott, et al.
  AFFIRMED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Justices Fowler, Edelman, and Draughn
  Trial court:  12th District Court (Hon. Erwin Ernst)
  For appellant:  Pro se
  For appellee:  S. Scott Shepherd


14-99-00433-CV

Alfred Bovati and Audrey Chreene
v.
Jason Renaud and Samuel Renaud
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Opinion by: Hon. J. Harvey Hudson
  Trial court:  Harris County Civil Court at Law No. 3 (Hon. Lynn Bradshaw-Hull)
  For appellant:  Joseph Onwuteaka
  For appellee:  Melanie L. Shelnutt and Frank D. Lanter


14-99-00434-CV

Don J. Davis, Individually, and Nucorp, Inc.
v.
Nations Bank of America, N. A.
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Fowler, Edelman, and Sondock
  Opinion by: Hon. Ruby Kless Sondock (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  Harris County Probate Court No. 4 (Hon. William C. McCulloch)
  For appellant:  J. Anthony Hale
  For appellee:  William E. Matthews


14-99-00751-CV

John King Davis
v.
Brazoria County Detention Center Inmate Trust Fund, et al.
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  23rd District Court (Hon. Robert E. May)
  For appellant:  Pro se
  For appellee:  John Cornyn


14-99-01253-CV

Frederick James Hebert
v.
Barbara Jane Hebert
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Justices Anderson, Fowler, and Edelman
  Trial court:  2nd and 25th District Court (Hon. Gus J. Strauss)
  For appellant:  Pro se
  For appellee:  Pro se


14-00-00145-CV

Tina Carter Nelson
v.
Micah Nelson
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  311th District Court (Hon. Doug Warne)
  For appellant:  Pro se
  For appellee:  John W. Wiggins


14-00-00498-CV

Helen Howard
v.
Petrostaff Services, Inc.
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Justices Amidei, Anderson, and Frost
  Trial court:  333rd District Court
  For appellant:  Pro se
  For appellee:  Chris C. Pappas and Heather Jolene Zubke


14-00-00641-CV

Robert Pina and JR Wings, Inc.
v.
Den-Dol, Inc.
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Justices Hudson, Fowler, and Edelman
  Trial court:  Brazos County Court at Law No. 2 (Hon. Jim Locke)
  For appellant:  Howard M. Kahn
  For appellee:  William Steven Steele, Patrice M. Barron, and Thomas R. Fox


14-00-00743-CV

Marion P. Shearer, Individually, and as Successor to Arthur G. Shearer, Deceased, Independent Executrix of the Estate of Arthur G. Shearer, Deceased
v.
Marjorie J. Barefield, Independent Executrix of the Estate of James Andrew Barefield, Deceased
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Justices Hudson, Fowler, and Edelman
  Trial court:  Harris County Probate Court No. 2 (Hon. Mike Wood)
  For appellant:  Christopher A. Prine
  For appellee:  John Henry Marshall


14-00-00757-CV

Ray Epps
v.
Hon. John Donovan
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  61st District Court (Hon. John Donovan)
  For appellant:  Ray Epps
  For appellee:  Pro se


14-00-00894-CV

H. L. McGee, Jr. and H. L. McGee, Jr., P.C.
v.
Philip E. Bryant and Philip E. Bryant, P.C.
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Justices Amidei, Anderson, and Frost
  Trial court:  125th District Court
  For appellant:  Henry Lee McGee
  For appellee:  John David Vogel


Criminal

Published:  

14-00-00354-CR
14-00-00355-CR
14-00-00356-CR

The State of Texas
v.
Andrew Garcia, Sean Robert Arterburn, and Fernando Ramos
  REVERSED AND REMANDED
  Panel: Justices Amidei, Anderson, and Frost
  Opinion by: Hon. Kem Thompson Frost
  Trial court:  Brazoria County Court at Law No. 3 (Hon. James Blackstock)
  For appellant:  Jessica J. Pulcher
  For appellee:  Victor R. Blaine


 
Unpublished: (Opinions not designated for publication have no precedential value and must not be cited as authority. See Tex. R. App. P. 47.7)

14-99-00033-CR

William Gary Warnecke
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Amidei, Anderson, and Maloney
  Opinion by: Hon. Frank Maloney (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  10th District Court (Hon. I. A. Lerner)
  For appellant:  Gregg Russell
  For appellee:  Joel H. Bennett


14-99-00065-CR

Colby Adon Wiggins
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Hudson, Fowler, and Edelman
  Opinion by: Hon. Wanda McKee Fowler
  Trial court:  182nd District Court (Hon. Woody Denson)
  For appellant:  Kristine C. Woldy
  For appellee:  Peyton Peebles, III


14-99-00070-CR

Robert D. Lavern
v.
The State of Texas
  REVERSED AND REMANDED
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Majority Opinion by: Hon. Don Wittig
  Dissenting Opinion by: Hon. J. Harvey Hudson
  Trial court:  338th District Court (Hon. Mary Bacon)
  For appellant:  Scott R. Courtney
  For appellee:  Barbara Anne Drumheller


14-99-00091-CR

Josue Baez Mata
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Opinion by: Hon. J. Harvey Hudson
  Trial court:  183rd District Court (Hon. Jay W. Burnett)
  For appellant:  Charles Thomas Flood
  For appellee:  Alan Curry


14-99-00260-CR

Andrew Motz
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Hudson, Fowler, and Edelman
  Opinion by: Hon. Wanda McKee Fowler
  Trial court:  Harris County Criminal Court at Law No. 3 (Hon. Donald Jackson)
  For appellant:  Clyde Williams
  For appellee:  Calvin A. Hartmann


14-99-00420-CR

John Garcia Soza
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Anderson, Frost, and Lee
  Opinion by: Hon. Norman Lee (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  176th District Court (Hon. Brian Rains)
  For appellant:  Steven C. Earl
  For appellee:  Calvin A. Hartmann


14-99-00547-CR

Adrian Vasquez, Jr.
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Opinion by: Hon. J. Harvey Hudson
  Trial court:  232nd District Court (Hon. Jon Hughes)
  For appellant:  David R. Bires
  For appellee:  Barbara Anne Drumheller


14-99-00578-CR

Robert Coleman Hayes
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Yates, Fowler, and Edelman
  Opinion by: Hon. Richard H. Edelman
  Trial court:  183rd District Court (Hon. Joan Huffman)
  For appellant:  Wayne Heller
  For appellee:  Payton Peebles, III


14-99-00628-CR

Ralph Basil Garcia
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  232nd District Court (Hon. Mary Lou Keel)
  For appellant:  Pro se
  For appellee:  Calvin A. Hartmann


14-99-00943-CR

Shonda Lizette Dunn
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  263rd District Court (Hon. Jim Wallace)
  For appellant:  Connie Brown Williams
  For appellee:  Calvin A. Hartmann


14-99-01138-CR

Frank Damont Berry
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Opinion by: Hon. J. Harvey Hudson
  Trial court:  179th District Court (Hon. William Hatten)
  For appellant:  Dan B. Gerson
  For appellee:  Rikke Burke Graber


14-00-00190-CR

Leonardo Manuel Lopez
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  183rd District Court (Hon. Joan Huffman)
  For appellant:  Connie Brown Williams
  For appellee:  Calvin A. Hartmann


14-00-00819-CR

The State of Texas
v.
Adam Lee Badgley
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  Brazos County Court at Law No. 2 (Hon. Jim Locke)
  For appellant:  James M. Kuboviak
  For appellee:  Pro se


14-00-00859-CR

Terrence Raymon Spellmon
v.
The State of Texas
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  176th District Court (Hon. Brian Rains)
  For appellant:  Pro se
  For appellee:  Calvin A. Hartmann


To view or print PDF files you must have the Adobe Acrobat® reader. This software may be obtained without charge from Adobe. Download the reader from the Adobe Web site.