Texas state seal

Historical Opinions

Fourteenth Court of Appeals
Houston, Texas

OPINIONS DATED MARCH 30, 2000


Civil

Published:  

14-99-00135-CV

Coastal Transport Company
v.
Crown Central Petroleum Corporation
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Anderson, Frost, and Lee
  Opinion by: Hon. Norman Lee (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  189th District Court (Hon. Carolyn Johnson)
  For appellant:  Robert M. Greenberg and Robert E. Motsenbocker
  For appellee:  M. Michael Meyer, John L. Hagan, and Robert Arredondo


14-99-00252-CV

In the Matter of G.A.T.
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Anderson, Frost, and Dunn
  Opinion by:  Hon. D. Camille Hutson-Dunn
  Trial court:  314th District Court (Hon. Mary Craft)
  For appellant:  William B. Connolly
  For appellee:  Dan McCrory


14-99-00492-CV

C. L. Bridges, Jeff Robinson, J. C. Romportl, J. E. Leach, Dillard's Department Store, City of Houston, Officer M. L. Hogan, Officer P. A. Davis, and Officer J. H. Theis
v.
Denise R. Robinson, Individually and on Behalf of the Estate of Darryl W. Robinson, Percy Robinson, and Irma Robinson
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Anderson, Frost, and Wittig
  Opinion by:  Hon. Don Wittig
  Trial court:  164th District Court (Hon. Katie Kennedy)
  For appellant:  Brock C. Akers, Evelyn T. Ailts Derrington, Kelly Ann Dempsey, Laura Anne Coats, Robert Anthony Armbruster, and Michael David Siemer
  For appellee:  Roger Rider



 
Unpublished: (Opinions not designated for publication have no precedential value and must not be cited as authority. See Tex. R. App. P. 47.7)

14-98-00145-CV

Bonnie Bucek and Milan Bucek, Individually and as Next Friends and Guardians of Marcus Bucek
v.
Fercan Kalkan and Fatima Kalkan, Individually and d/b/a College Real Estate Management Co., and Sefa Koseoglu and Pia Koseoglu
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Justices Cannon, Draughn, and Lee (Metropolitan Backlog Reduction Force)
  Opinion by: Hon. Bill Cannon (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  272nd District Court (Hon. John M. Delaney)
  For appellant:  Pete T. Patterson and John L. Barnes
  For appellee:  Joseph Paul Horlen and Wayne T. Rife


14-98-00234-CV

United States Automobile Association
v.
Underwriters at Interest and Steven Richard Bishop, Representative of Lloyd's, London Cover Note EE8800246, Each Severally but Not Jointly
  AFFIRMED (on rehearing)
  Panel:  Justices Amidei, Edelman, and Wittig
  Opinion by:  Hon. Richard H. Edelman
  Trial court:  152nd District Court (Hon. Jack O'Neill)
  For appellant:  H. Lee Lewis, Jr.
  For appellee:  C. Vance Christopher


14-98-01025-CV

Corina Scott
v.
Dr. Ray M. Fitzgerald M.D., Dr. Andrew P. Kant M.D., KSF Orthopeadic Center, et al.
  AFFIRMED IN PART; REVERSED AND REMANDED IN PART
  Panel:  Justices Draughn, Lee, and Dunn (Metropolitan Backlog Reduction Task Force)
  Opinion by: Hon. Norman Lee (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  333rd District Court (Hon. Joseph Halbach)
  For appellant:  J. Ronald Tucker
  For appellee:  John P. Scott, Solace Kirkland Southwick, Jeffrey B. McClure, and David Wayne Clawater


14-99-00055-CV

Ralf Franz Brehm
v.
Angela Marie Brehm
  AFFIRMED
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Opinion by: Hon. Paul C. Murphy
  Trial court:  310th District Court (Hon. Lisa Millard)
  For appellant:  Kenneth C. Kaye
  For appellee:  Jolene Wilson-Glah and Patricia Nellenbach Carter


14-99-00614-CV

Handy Spot
v.
Richard B. Williamson
  AFFIRMED IN PART; DISMISSED IN PART (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Justices Yates, Fowler, and Edelman
  Trial court:  Harris County Civil Court at Law No. 4 (Hon. Cynthia Crowe)
  For appellant:  Patrick Gailey
  For appellee:  Douglas Moran


14-99-00790-CV

Constable A. B. Chambers and Deputy Constable Darren Francis
v.
Andre Hornsby, Ethel Hornsby, Aaron McGilbrida, and Kehlin Faroag
  REVERSED AND REMANDED
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Majority Opinion by: Hon. Paul C. Murphy
  Concurring and Dissenting Opinion by: Hon. Don Wittig
  Trial court:  189th District Court (Hon. Jeff Work)
  For appellant:  Michael R. Hull
  For appellee:  John E. Sherman


14-99-01267-CV

Ramco Freight Services, Inc.
v.
Ronald Wortham
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  113th District Court (Hon. Patricia Hancock)
  For appellant:  Manuel Robert Garcia
  For appellee:  Deborah Lee Bradley


14-00-00242-CV

Dennis John Giammarco
v.
Davida Ellen Irving
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel:  Justices Yates, Fowler, and Edelman
  Trial court:  245th District Court (Hon. Annette Galik)
  For appellant:  John E. Van Ness
  For appellee:  Stewart W. Gagnon



Criminal

Published:  

14-97-01199-CR

Frank T. Linton
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Yates, Fowler, and Frost
  Opinion by:  Hon. Wanda McKee Fowler
  Trial court:  183rd District Court (Hon. Robert D. Jones)
  For appellant:  Ronald Hayes
  For appellee:  Rikke Burke Graber


14-98-01315-CR

Tom George
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Majority Opinion by:  Hon. J. Harvey Hudson
  Dissenting Opinion by: Hon. Paul C. Murphy
  Trial court:  Harris County Criminal Court at Law No. 13 (Hon. Mark Atkinson and Hon. Jean Hughes)
  For appellant:  Mike DeGeurin
  For appellee:  Alan Curry

14-99-00261-CR
14-99-00262-CR

Roy Edward Addicks, Jr.
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Anderson, Frost, and Lee (sitting by assignment)
  Opinion by: Hon. John S. Anderson
  Trial court:  183rd District Court (Hon. Joan Huffman)
  For appellant:  Jay T. Karahan
  For appellee:  S. Elaine Roch



 
Unpublished: (Opinions not designated for publication have no precedential value and must not be cited as authority. See Tex. R. App. P. 47.7)

14-97-00959-CR

Maureen M. Millen
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Cannon, Draughn, and Dunn (Metropolitan Backlog Reduction Force)
  Opinion by:  Hon. Joe Draughn (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  337th District Court (Hon. William Hatten)
  For appellant:  Patrick McCann
  For appellee:  S. Elaine Roch

14-98-00134-CR
14-98-00135-CR

Homouz K. Nabulsi
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Robertson, Sears, and Lee (Metropolitan Backlog Reduction Force)
  Opinion by: Hon. Ross A. Sears (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  184th District Court (Hon. Jan Krocker)
  For appellant:  Henry L. Burkholder, III
  For appellee:  Keli Pool Roper


14-98-00200-CR

John F. Bogany
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Yates, Fowler, and Frost
  Opinion by:  Hon. Leslie Brock Yates
  Trial court:  337th District Court (Hon. Jon Hughes)
  For appellant:  Henry L. Burkholder, III
  For appellee:  Kimberly Aperauch Stelter


14-98-00201-CR

Henry Antonio Mora
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Edelman, Wittig, and Baird
  Opinion by:  Hon. Charles F. Baird (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  232nd District Court (Hon. Joseph M. Guarino)
  For appellant:  Ricardo N. Gonzalez
  For appellee:  Kimberly Aperauch Stelter


14-98-00441-CR

Hurman Luvell Williams
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Robertson, Sears, and Lee (Metropolitan Backlog Reduction Force)
  Opinion by: Hon. Norman Lee (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  183rd District Court (Hon. Pat Lykos)
  For appellant:  Leroy Peavy and R. Scott Shearer
  For appellee:  Barbara Anne Drumheller


14-98-00468-CR
14-98-00739-CR

Clifton Thomas Holliday
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Robertson, Sears, and Lee (Metropolitan Backlog Reduction Force)
  Opinion by: Hon. Norman Lee (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  208th District Court (Hon. Denise Collins)
  For appellant:  Charles A. Brown
  For appellee:  Carol M. Cameron


14-98-00493-CR

David V. Elizondo
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Anderson and Hudson
  Opinion by: Hon. J. Harvey Hudson
  Trial court:  208th District Court (Hon. Denise Collins)
  For appellant:  Allen C. Isbell
  For appellee:  Alan Curry


14-98-00519-CR

David Field Howard
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Robertson, Sears, and Lee (Metropolitan Backlog Reduction Force)
  Opinion by: Hon. Norman Lee (sitting by assignment)
  Trial court:  185th District Court (Hon. H. Lon Harper)
  For appellant:  Alain G. Harvey
  For appellee:  S. Elaine Roch


14-98-00650-CR

Vince Edward Mize
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Yates, Fowler, and Frost
  Opinion by: Hon. Kem Thompson Frost
  Trial court:  180th District Court (Hon. Debbie M. Stricklin)
  For appellant:  Sylvia Yarborough
  For appellee:  Carol M. Cameron

14-99-00067-CR

Anthony T. Johnson
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED AS MODIFIED
  Panel: Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Opinion by: Hon. J. Harvey Hudson
  Trial court:  180th District Court (Hon. Debbie M. Stricklin)
  For appellant:  Joan O. Nwuli
  For appellee:  Carmen Castillo Mitchell

14-99-00211-CR

Latorsha Requil Holman
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  339th District Court (Hon. Caprice Cosper)
  For appellant:  Alex G. Azzo
  For appellee:  Kelly Ann Smith

14-99-00461-CR

Jose Luis Arellano
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Justices Yates, Fowler, and Edelman
  Opinion by: Hon. Richard H. Edelman
  Trial court:  184th District Court (Hon. Jan Krocker)
  For appellant:  Tony Aninao
  For appellee:  Calvin A. Hartmann

14-99-00544-CR

Willie Wright
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Trial court:  183rd District Court (Hon. Joan Huffman)
  For appellant:  Juan M. Contreras
  For appellee:  Rikke Burke Graber

14-99-00622-CR
14-99-00623-CR

Sammy Ray Moy
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson and Wittig
  Opinion by: Hon. Paul C. Murphy
  Trial court:  179th District Court (Hon. Mike Wilkerson)
  For appellant:  Ronald G. Ray
  For appellee:  Carol M. Cameron


14-99-00652-CR

Bill Marcus Tutor
v.
The State of Texas
  AFFIRMED
  Panel: Chief Justice Murphy and Justices Hudson, and Wittig
  Opinion by: Hon. Don Wittig
  Trial court:  21st District Court (Hon. Harold R. Towslee)
  For appellant:  Jim W. James
  For appellee:  Michael J. West


14-00-00224-CR

Thomas Albert Palmer
v.
The State of Texas
  DISMISSED (Per curiam)
  Panel: Justices Yates, Fowler, and Edelman
  Trial court:  230th District Court (Hon. Belinda Hill)
  For appellant:  Tom Zakes
  For appellee:  Calvin A. Hartmann


To view or print PDF files you must have the Adobe Acrobat® reader. This software may be obtained without charge from Adobe. Download the reader from the Adobe Web site.